This is a nice replacement top. The material was nicer than the original one I got with my gazebo. It was also sewn more durable than my original and had more Velcro straps to hold it down. The only thing that did not fit correctly was the very top cover. It is about 2" too short, but has Velcro straps to hold it down. It doesn't bother me too much because I don't spend any time looking at the top cover, and it still keeps me covered from underneath. As always, don't leave it up in high winds or heavy rains/snow, because that will quickly degrade your top.
I will purchase again if I need a new top again.
Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this to a friend